This is Tibetan plateau, a vast elevated plateau in Central Asia and East Asia, covering most of the Tibet Autonomous Region and Qinghai in western China, as well as part of Ladakh in Jammu and Kashmir, India.
It stretches approximately 1,000 kilometres (620 mi) north to south and 2,500 kilometres (1,600 mi) east to west. With an average elevation exceeding 4,500 metres (14,800 ft), the Tibetan Plateau is sometimes called "the Roof of the World" because it stands over 3 miles (4.8 km) above sea level and is surrounded by imposing mountain ranges that harbor the world's two highest summits, Mount Everest and K2, and is the world's highest and largest plateau, with an area of 2,500,000 square kilometres (970,000 sq mi).
The plateau is the home to Tibetan people and Sherpa people.
And these people have a very interesting legend. The legend of Yeti. In the folklore of Tibetan plateau, the Yeti or Abominable Snowman is an ape-like creature, taller than an average human, that is said to inhabit the Himalayan region of Nepal, Bhutan, and Tibet. The legend says that during the snow storms Yeti comes down from the mountains to the villages and steals local women. The legend of Yeti was widely publicised by the western explorers who not only believed in it but also contributed to it by stories of encounters with Yeti during their expeditions.
The scientific community has generally regarded the Yeti as a legend, given the lack of evidence of its existence. Recently, a genetic study was undertaken during which all the artefacts found throughout the region which were attributed to Yeti (bones, claws, hair) were analysed. The DNA from the samples was matched with Himalayan, Tibetan and Eurasian brown bears and Asian black bears DNA. Based on these results, the researchers concluded that the belief in Yetis has its roots in biological facts and is based on human encounters with bears that still live in the region today. The researchers also concluded that the existence of a large hairy ape like creature in the Himalayan-Tibetan region is indeed a myth which has no base in reality.
And this is where the story of Yeti would have ended. If it wasn't for the strange DNA of the people from Tibetan plateau. Both Tibetan and Sherpa populations are genetically most similar to each other and then to other modern East Asian and Central Asian populations. However there is something very interesting about people from the Tibetan plateau. After modern Oceanic populations, modern Tibetan populations show the highest rate of allele sharing with archaic hominins at over 6%. Modern Tibetans show genetic affinities to three archaic populations: Denisovans, Neanderthals, and an unidentified archaic population. Once scientists started looking closely at these archaic DNA sequences, they discovered something very very interesting.
Researchers have long wondered how Tibetans live and work at altitudes above 4000 meters, where the limited supply of oxygen makes most people sick. Other high-altitude people, such as Andean highlanders, have adapted to such thin air by adding more oxygen-carrying hemoglobin to their blood. But Tibetans have adapted by having less hemoglobin in their blood; scientists think this trait helps them avoid serious problems, such as clots and strokes caused when the blood thickens with more hemoglobin-laden red blood cells.
In 2010 geneticists discovered that Tibetans have several genes that help them use smaller amounts of oxygen efficiently, allowing them to deliver enough of it to their limbs while exercising at high altitude. Most notable is a version of a gene called EPAS1, which regulates the body’s production of hemoglobin. These genes are not found in any other human population outside of Tibetan plateau.
Since this gene was discovered the scientists wandered where it came from. And then in 2014, while looking through the genes found in Denisovans DNA, they spotted EPAS1. The mystery was solved. The "superathlete" gene, which helps Sherpas and other Tibetans breathe easily at high altitudes was inherited from Denisovans, one of the archaic human species now extinct.
But there is the problem. It is commonly accepted that Denisovans went extinct soon after they mated with the ancestors of Europeans and Asians about 40,000 years ago. So the only time when Tibetans could have acquired EPAS1 gene is at that time. But it is also commonly accepted that the Tibetan plateau has only been inhabited by humans for around 15,000 years. Now considering that Tibetan plateau population is the only one in the world which possesses the EPAS1 gene, it is most likely that they acquired it on the Tibetan plateau. Which means that either Denisovans survived on the Tibetan plateau until 14,000 years ago (35,000 years longer then anywhere else in the world), or that modern humans arrived to Tibetan plateau much much earlier than originally thought.
But this is not the biggest problem that this genetic discovery poses.
Within Tibetan mythology, the origins of Tibetans are said to be rooted in the marriage of the monkey Pha Trelgen Changchup Sempa and rock ogress Ma Drag Sinmo.
Now this is very very interesting legend.
Remember the legend about Yeti. Yeti was a huge hairy ape like creature which came down from the mountains and stole women from the villages. Presumably to mate with them...
The Tibetan origin myth is the exact opposite of the the Yeti legend. It is a legend about the hairy mountain monkey who was seduced by a white female demon who came up to the mountain and who wanted to mate with him...
In both cases the hairy mountain monkey and female that came to (or was brought to) the mountain produced offspring which became the ancestors of the Tibetan plateau population. The population which is the mix of Denisovans (big hairy smart apes???) and modern humans. The population which has the bigger amount of Denisovans DNA than any other human population. The population which is the only human population which inherited the Denisovans high altitude gene EPAS1 which allows people to survive on the roof of the world...
And here is the question: Are these Tibetan plateau legends about mating between humans and huge, smart hairy apes from the mountains memories of the actual mixing between the modern humans who arrived to the Tibetan plateau and Denisovans who they found there?
No, that is not possible, I can hear people say. That mixing occurred at some stage between 14,000 and 40,000 years ago. No memory can survive that long...
Well...Remember my post "Dreamtime"? In it I talked about the fact that we now have proof that some Australian Aboriginal legends are actual histories which are over 45,000 years old...
So it is actually quite possible that these Tibetan plateau legends are also histories which have been preserved as legends for tens of thousands of years.
But why am I talking about the legend of Yeti in the blog about Old European Culture? Well how old are European legends???
PS: Well it turns out that recent archaeological discoveries prove that modern humans did actually arrive to Tibet right on time to first intermix with Denisovans, acquiring the high altitude gene and then exterminate them.
The Nwya Devu Paleolithic site discovered by this team confirms that human ancestors set foot on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau at elevations approaching 5,000 meters above sea level around 30,000-40,000 years ago. It is the first Paleolithic archaeological site discovered in Tibet that preserves intact stratigraphy allowing age-dating of the site’s antiquity. Nwya Devu is located in the Changthang region of northern Tibet, about 300 km northwest of Lhasa, the capital of Tibet Autonomous Region, at about 4,600 meters above sea level.
Very interesting, thanks for researching these monkey x demon & human x yeti hybrid stories.
ReplyDeleteBut I think this is incorrect: "The population which has the bigger amount of Denisovans DNA than any other human population." The Australians, Papuans and Philippine Mamanwa all have much higher total Denisovan genes (~ 6%?) than Tibetans, but I think they lack the specific low-hemoglobin sequence that Tibetans have. Chinese and other East Asians also have some (~ 1%?) Denisovan sequences, but again, I think they also lack the low-hemoglobin sequence.
I didn't think Tibetans are much hairier than other East Asians, but unsure.
I was recently watching a documentary about Himalayan Snub-nosed monkeys and I was fascinated by their looks. Their strange, almost mystical appearance inevitably made me associate them with the Yeti legend. So if these primates inhabit mountain areas up to a height of 4,000m , I would presume that they also possess a similar mutation.
ReplyDeleteNATURE | Mystery Monkeys of Shangri-La | Preview | PBS
https://youtu.be/9--ZX8-f1uc
I hope I may be forgiven for repeating myself, but E. J. Michael Witzel, in "The Origins of the World's Mythologies," traces Eurasian myths back some 40,000 years or so. So, I don't think 15,000 years is very long for a myth to survive (and evolve).
ReplyDeleteIs it possible his 'Laurasian storyline' is of neanderthal origins? Think where its distributed.
Delete"She threatened that if he refused to sleep with her she would visit a demon and conceive a multitude of small monsters that would destroy all living creatures. The wise monkey yielded and married her."
ReplyDeleteBest seduction strategy ever!
"And this is where the story of Yeti would have ended. If it wasn't for the strange DNA of the people from Tibetan plateau. Both Tibetan and Sherpa populations are genetically most similar to each other and then to other modern East Asian and Central Asian populations. However there is something very interesting about people from the Tibetan plateau. After modern Oceanic populations, modern Tibetan populations show the highest rate of allele sharing with archaic hominins at over 6%."
ReplyDeleteMore seriously, it ought to be possible to very accurately date the time of admixture using linkage disequilibrium methods, and I'd be somewhat surprised if the paper announcing the result didn't try to do so.
White peoples' fault - a white woman in this case. I knew it.
ReplyDeleteAre nepalese people yetis
ReplyDeleteYour article is already 5 years old, but thanks for these musings.
ReplyDeleteI think that this new angle to the yeti myth is very intriguing - especially since a jawbone of a Denisovan has been discovered in a cave in the Himalayas in 2019. These guys were definitely at home in yeti territory, and they have definitely mixed with the ancestors of the Tibetans!
Today we know that oral traditions and the preservation of ancient memories can indeed bridge huge time spans. Since the discovery of homo floresiensis aka the hobbits of Flores, we have another example of ancient hominins who probably shared their habitat with homo sapiens for a while. And the indigenous people from that island have told for ages stories about annoying pint-sized bipedal creatures whom they call ebu gogo. They had the deplorable habit of stealing food and babies - until the humans reacted very human-like and extinguished these creatures by burning them in a cave 😞 This narrative is quite plausible, and ebu gogo might've indeed been inspired by homo floresiensis. Therefore it's not at all unreasonable to speculate that the Denisovans of the Himalayas inspired yeti stories!